name that tune

i've recently started playing this game called "The Tone Deaf Challenge" at a local bar. basically it's like playing "name that tune," but with teams and lightning rounds. they play the first few bars of a song, and you have to guess what it is.

last night, they played "you + me = us" by that mtv band 2gether... and i just could NOT remember the name of the band. i'm still ticked. i should have know that shit! we were a little boy band crazy in high school.